Saturday, December 12, 2015

The Arranged Marriage

I particularly enjoyed the short story “This Blessed House” from Interpreter of the Maladies. I was able to relate to the story in some sense because my parents met in almost the same exact way as Twinkle and Sanjiv. My mother and father met because their families were good friends. In India, people still refer to this kind of arrangement as an arranged marriage even though it is definitely a more modern version. Traditionally, arranged marriages implied that two people were put together by their parents early on in their childhood and were to be married when they reached a certain age. The kind of arrangement ( the one between Sanjeev and Twinkle and my mother and father) is different because both individuals had a choice to decide whether or not they were interested and wanted to get married. I feel like, from the bits and pieces that I have heard, the early years of my mother and fathers relationship (and the context in which they got married) was similar to the relationship of Twinkle and Sanjeev in “This Blessed House”.
We talked about in class how Sanjiv seems to already have his life planned out for himself. From what I have gathered through personal observations from my father, most Indian men seem to have a stage in life when they deem it “time” to get married and start a family. Aside from the obvious similarity, my father’s name is Sanjiv and Sanjeev is the name of the husband in the story, both my dad and Sanjeev were in a similar stage of life when they got married .My father was 28 years old and had just completed his second degree and had settled down and was working a job when he started searching or opening up to the prospect of getting married. Sanjeev, who is 33 years old, also seems to be reasonably successful in his job as he has a secretary working for him as well as a dozen people under him. Both Sanjeev, and my father Sanjiv, had completed their education and had settled down and reached some success with their jobs. In Indian culture, it is rare for men to marry before they are in their mid twenties. It seems as if there is the sense that Indian men should have a job and have some financial stability before they find a wife. 

Throughout this entire story, I kept thinking about how risky a marriage like this seems. Meeting someone and marrying them only a few months later doesn't sound like a good idea to me. I feel like people should have a period of time where they live together to determine if they are a good match. When I was reading the story, I kept thinking that Sanjeev and Twinkle don't seem like a good fit because of how opposite their personalities and interests are. My parents were married only two months after them met. In this story, Sanjeev and Twinkle married within a few moths as well. My parents have told me that they, similar to Sanjeev and Twinkle, did experience quite a bit of tension and conflict during their first few months as a couple. They then realized that they will each have to give up certain things in order to be happy. It does seem like Sanjeev and Twinkle are slowly starting to make compromises as well. I think if they continue to do so, they can have a long relationship just like my parents. 

10 comments:

  1. Yeah, in class when you brought up the arranged marriage tradition I realized just how odd it seems to me. I think it's really awesome that your parent's marriage worked out, but it seems like such a strange tradition, especially because it is not something I see often in American culture. Meeting someone for the first time with the knowledge that you are expected to marry them only a few months later just seems so strange. Just meeting someone and going on dates and knowing that no matter how well it goes you are expected to marry them...it just seems so foreign. I definitely like the more American custom of relationships, but perhaps that is just because that's the norm I grew up with. Either way, good and thought provoking blog post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Im glad you found my blog thought provoking. I definitely agree with your assessment. It does seem crazy to think that arranged marriages do in the end most of the time work out. I just feel like it would be so easy to fight about something or the other because arranged marriages are kind of a mystery. You really don't know what you're getting yourself into.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm with Siena here. Arranged marriages seems really odd and different to me. I'm glad that a lot of them work out, but at the same time, hearing that there is a lot of uneasiness and unhappiness in the beginning just makes me a bit sad. It seems unhealthy to be stuck in that predicament where you are just finding things out about someone you'll (probably) spend the rest of your life with and realize you don't match well. In the end, someone would have to change a lot in this story for it to work out well. I'm all for change, but in small amounts. But here there would have to be major personality changes. Twinkle would have to mellow out and loose her charm or Sanjeev would have to relax and become more child like. Changing so much for someone else just seems wrong to me, especially when they're happy and lots of people like them for the type of person they are.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The marriage of Twinkle and Sanjeev is sort of an "Americanized" version of an arranged marriage, as far as I understand it. They are clearly "set up" by mutual friends, who believe they'd be a good match, and they understand that this is why they are being invited and made to sit next to each other, but there isn't a formal "arrangement" being made--they freely choose to get married, but again, they do it very quickly (by most contemporary American standards), and they don't know each other very well when they start living together as husband and wife. So in that sense, it has a lot of the same qualities as a more traditional version of the arranged marriage.

    And I said so in class, but I'm strongly in the pro-Twinkle camp (I agree with Sanjeev's co-workers!)--spending more time with her will be good for this guy, who really does need to relax and not worry so much about what is proper. Or maybe I'm just biased in favor of English majors.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Interesting connections! I really enjoyed how you were able to draw similarities between Sanjeev/Twinkle and your parents and then predict the outcome of Sanjeev and Twinkle's marriage by looking at the marriage of your own parents. I think most people agreed that both Sanjeev and Twinkle would have to sacrifice and make compromises in order to have a happy marriage, just like your parents did. Although Sanjeev and Twinkle do have problems with each other, I personally don't think that these problems are so bad that they cannot be dealt with compromises. I also predicted that Sanjeev and Twinkle would eventually find a way around their differences and end up enjoying their marriage.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It's clear that the tensions in the story are caused by the lack of time together prior to marriage. I don't think they had any time living together before marriage, thus having little idea of the other partner's life style and habits (which is the source of tension in the story). I know that many arranged marriages do work out, like your parents', but I recall Pranav said talking about relationship issues was taboo in Indian culture. I wonder how many people are locked in arranged marriages that truly do not fit and are too afraid to speak out.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The aspect of arranged marriages working themselves out is something that we don't really see in western culture. Other than the lack of arranged marriages, divorce is often seen as a viable option, which may not be in Indian culture. I do think that the marriage in "This Blessed House" would work out, especially if both seek compromise as the main problem solving solution. The fact they Twinkle and Sanjiv have very different personalities seems to be the main problem, and I don't really know how much either are willing to compromise their personalities to support the marriage, but if they do the marriage could last for a very long time.

    ReplyDelete
  9. haha Mr. Mitchell. I too was particularly drawn towards Twinkle as a character in the story. She seemed like a fun person to be around and get to know. Sanjeev just doesn't have the social skills, nor the ability to relax and chill out like Twinkle does. I agree with your assessment of the arranged marriage and how Twinkle and Sanjeev's version was definitely a more westernized version. However, I do still feel like "arranged marriages" in India are becoming more Americanized and the definition in slowly starting to change. Also, I completely agree with Pranav on his thoughts as well.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think Lahiri does a really good job of giving us a broad picture of Sanjeev and Twinkle’s relationship from a very specific event(s), finding the Christian objects. After reading this story, I really wondered if Twinkle and Sanjeev would stay together. The ending was so ambiguous, you could have read it like he was starting to open up to Twinkle’s perspective or that he was once again grudgingly putting up with her antics.

    ReplyDelete